Hey guys,
I would like to hear opinions on Saving Private Ryan especially from non American viewers. Mainly looking for any problems you have with the movie. Please also give your overall rating even if you have problems with it. Please be as brutally honest as possible and I will let you know why you are wrong.Thanks in advance.
Does this belong in the ASL forum?
"Does this belong in the ASL forum?"
Does a lot of the stuff we talk about belong in the ASL forum?
Afterall, didn't someone do another post/thread on WWII movies?
Or for that matter, if we are going to be picky, does a thread a SL belong in an ASL forum?
Or how about the thread on a trip to Holland?
Lets not get too picky. SPR is about WWII.
Peace
Roger
Last edited by rdw5150; 03 Mar 05 at 15:03.
"once in a while
you get shown the light
in the strangest of places
if you look at it right" -J.Garcia/R.Hunter, "Scarlet Begonias"
Maybe not but you guys do discuss other things besides ASL sometimes. Just curious what you guys think of this movie. I have seen many Europeans bashing the movie for various reasons. I wanted to get opinions from some intelligent people (assuming you must be particularly intelligent to play ASL) who are knowledgable in World War II instead of some movie watchers that think they are experts.Originally Posted by Pitman
I'm european and non-ASLer so I guess that makes me doubly incompetent to discuss SPR
probably not - this should be posted in the forums at www.imdb.com
No, I would like your opinion especially since you are from Europe.I'm european and non-ASLer so I guess that makes me doubly incompetent to discuss SPR
That is exactly the reason I am asking it here. The posts on imdb usually turn into US bashing vs UK bashing because of the "experts" that read the internet or watch a movie and suddenly are WW2 historians.probably not - this should be posted in the forums at www.imdb.com
Like I said earlier, I am asking people that look to be more intelligent and have knowledge on the subject just from playing ASL and other games (and probably read tons of books on WW2). I have yet to see bashing of anyone based on their nationality.
Now I got it. Two threads by me, an ASL newbie, about non ASL topics. Wanting to know where to go to Holland so I could apply WWII knowledge to my game and if it was worth it to get that old original SL gear from a co-worker..."Does this belong in the ASL forum?"
Or for that matter, if we are going to be picky, does a thread a SL belong in an ASL forum?
Or how about the thread on a trip to Holland?
Lets not get too picky. SPR is about WWII
Peace
Roger
I certainly don't think anything WWII is out of place but then again, I'm the culprit of two of those posts. You could sue me I guess, but Canada would have to deport me first.
Last edited by Josh; 03 Mar 05 at 15:58.
I would not worry about it. Most of the people on here seem nice and helpful but sometimes the old vets get a bit grumpy. There is discussion of other things outside of ASL. I love the game too but my world does not revolve around it (I think it revolves around meNow I got it. Two threads by me, an ASL newbie, about non ASL topics. Wanting to know where to go to Holland so I could apply WWII knowledge to my game and if it was worth it to get that old original SL gear from a co-worker... Sorry...
I certainly don't think anything WWII is out of place Mark but then again, I'm the culprit of two of those posts. You could sue me I guess, but Canada would have to deport me first.)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks